Hi Peter,
On 15.03.21 19:56, Peter Schober wrote:
Case in point: Bernd O. on this list would rather remove the most obvious and direct method of accessing an SP -- open its home page and "log in" -- than release a pseudonymous identifier to an SP for personalisation purposes. (I.e., the reservation here is not even specific to /optional/ personalisation, which I'm discussing here, but to any kind of personalisation based on a privacy-preserving identifier provided by the institution):
- Bernd Oberknapp bo@ub.uni-freiburg.de [2021-03-13 14:40]:
If publishers would force us to send an eduPersonTargetedID just for personalization I would consider dropping Shibboleth for those publishers and using our EZproxy instead.
just to clarify: I would only consider this if the SP would force us to send an eduPersonTargetedID (or any other attribte/identifier that allows to recognize returning users) for all users, i.e. by making it a requirement for using the institutional login. I don't have a problem with an optional attribute, i.e. if the user can choose whether to release that attribute for personalization or not.
Best regards, Bernd